| Sep 18 06:00 | TS | 46 mph | — | 18.2°N 79.2°W | 56 mi W of Negril, Jamaica |
| Sep 18 12:00 | TS | 58 mph | — | 18.2°N 79.8°W | 95 mi W of Negril, Jamaica |
| Sep 18 18:00 | TS | 69 mph | 994 mb | 18.3°N 80.4°W | 86 mi SE of Frank Sound, Cayman Islands |
| Sep 19 00:00 | Cat 1 | 81 mph | — | 18.5°N 80.8°W | 61 mi SSE of Bodden Town, Cayman Islands |
| Sep 19 06:00 | Cat 1 | 92 mph | — | 18.8°N 81.1°W | 34 mi SSE of Bodden Town, Cayman Islands |
| Sep 19 12:00 | Cat 2 | 104 mph | — | 19.2°N 81.5°W | 10 mi SW of George Town, Cayman Islands |
| Sep 19 18:00 | Cat 3 | 121 mph | 951 mb | 19.6°N 81.9°W | 36 mi WNW of West Bay, Cayman Islands |
| Sep 20 00:00 | Cat 3 | 127 mph | — | 20.0°N 82.2°W | 68 mi NW of West Bay, Cayman Islands |
| Sep 20 06:00 | Cat 3 | 127 mph | — | 20.5°N 82.3°W | 97 mi NW of West Bay, Cayman Islands |
| Sep 20 12:00 | Cat 3 | 127 mph | — | 21.2°N 82.3°W | 58 mi SE of Nueva Gerona, Isla de la Juventud, Cuba |
| Sep 20 18:00 | Cat 3 | 127 mph | — | 21.9°N 82.3°W | 32 mi E of Nueva Gerona, Isla de la Juventud, Cuba |
| Sep 20 22:00 | Cat 3 LANDFALL | 127 mph | — | 22.3°N 82.1°W | 31 mi SSE of Batabanó, Mayabeque, Cuba |
| Sep 21 00:00 | Cat 3 | 127 mph | — | 22.6°N 82.1°W | 17 mi SSW of Güines, Mayabeque, Cuba |
| Sep 21 01:00 | Cat 3 LANDFALL | 127 mph | — | 22.7°N 82.0°W | 10 mi S of Güines, Mayabeque, Cuba |
| Sep 21 06:00 | Cat 3 | 115 mph | — | 23.3°N 81.9°W | 10 mi N of Santa Cruz del Norte, Mayabeque, Cuba |
| Sep 21 12:00 | Cat 3 | 121 mph | — | 24.0°N 81.7°W | 39 mi S of Key West, Florida |
| Sep 21 17:00 | Cat 3 LANDFALL | 121 mph | 955 mb | 24.6°N 81.6°W | 12 mi ENE of Key West, Florida |
| Sep 21 18:00 | Cat 3 | 121 mph | 955 mb | 24.7°N 81.5°W | 20 mi ENE of Key West, Florida |
| Sep 22 00:00 | Cat 4 | 132 mph | — | 25.4°N 81.4°W | 42 mi SSE of Marco Island, Florida |
| Sep 22 05:00 | Cat 4 LANDFALL | 132 mph | 940 mb | 25.8°N 81.3°W | 28 mi ESE of Marco Island, Florida |
| Sep 22 06:00 | Cat 4 | 132 mph | 940 mb | 26.0°N 81.2°W | 32 mi SSE of Immokalee, Florida |
| Sep 22 12:00 | Cat 2 | 98 mph | — | 26.5°N 80.8°W | 15 mi SSW of Belle Glade, Florida |
| Sep 22 18:00 | Cat 1 | 92 mph | 965 mb | 27.3°N 80.1°W | 15 mi E of Port Saint Lucie, Florida |
| Sep 23 00:00 | Cat 1 | 92 mph | — | 27.9°N 78.9°W | 84 mi N of West End, Bahamas |
| Sep 23 06:00 | Cat 2 | 98 mph | — | 28.5°N 77.6°W | 151 mi NNE of Lucaya, Bahamas |
| Sep 23 12:00 | Cat 2 | 104 mph | — | 29.6°N 75.7°W | open ocean |
| Sep 23 18:00 | Cat 2 | 104 mph | — | 31.0°N 73.6°W | open ocean |
| Sep 24 00:00 | Cat 2 | 98 mph | — | 33.0°N 71.6°W | open ocean |
| Sep 24 06:00 | Cat 1 extratropical | 86 mph | — | 35.1°N 69.5°W | open ocean |
| Sep 24 12:00 | Cat 1 extratropical | 75 mph | — | 37.1°N 66.9°W | open ocean |
| Sep 24 18:00 | TS extratropical | 69 mph | — | 39.3°N 62.0°W | open ocean |
| Sep 25 00:00 | TS extratropical | 63 mph | — | 41.5°N 57.5°W | open ocean |
| Sep 25 06:00 | TS extratropical | 58 mph | — | 43.3°N 52.8°W | open ocean |
| Sep 25 12:00 | TS extratropical | 52 mph | — | 44.6°N 48.6°W | open ocean |
| Sep 25 18:00 | TS extratropical | 52 mph | — | 46.0°N 43.7°W | open ocean |
| Sep 26 00:00 | TS extratropical | 52 mph | — | 47.5°N 39.0°W | open ocean |